SurePayroll vs GTM: Which Nanny Payroll Service Costs Less?
Hiring a nanny, caregiver or housekeeper makes you an employer. Both of these services run household payroll and file the taxes. One costs a lot less than the other.
Prices checked on each company's own pricing page on Oct 30, 2026. They change often, so check before you sign up.
SurePayroll vs GTM at a glance
| SurePayroll Household | GTM EasyPay | |
|---|---|---|
| Base price | $39/mo | From $70/mo |
| Per person | First employee included | First employee included, then $20/mo each |
| Payroll tax filing | Federal and state, filed and deposited automatically | Federal, state and local, prepared and filed |
| Contractor payments | Supports W-2 employees and 1099 contractors | Not listed on its pricing page |
| Free trial or promo | 6 months free over your first year | None listed. Setup included, one-month minimum. |
| Tax ID setup | State tax ID registration help | Gets your federal and state tax IDs for you |
What one nanny costs
With one employee, SurePayroll Household is $39 a month and GTM EasyPay starts at $70 a month. Add a second employee and GTM goes to $90.
Which one to pick
- SurePayroll if you want the lowest price and are fine running payroll from an app. Its free months cut the first year even more.
- GTM if you want them to set up your tax IDs, file local taxes, and give unlimited audit support.
Paying a business team instead? See our payroll price chart for 2026.
FAQ
How much does nanny payroll cost?
SurePayroll Household is $39/mo with one employee included. GTM EasyPay starts at $70/mo with the first employee included and $20/mo for each extra employee.
Why use a payroll service for a nanny?
When you hire in-home help, you're responsible for their payroll taxes and the year-end forms. A household payroll service calculates, files and pays those taxes for you and makes the W-2 and Schedule H.
Does SurePayroll do Schedule H?
Yes. It files your federal and state household payroll taxes and gives you a signature-ready Schedule H and your W-2s.
Is GTM worth paying more for?
It can be if you want more hands-on help. GTM gets your tax IDs for you, files local taxes, includes unlimited audit support and has HR plans for bigger households.
Related deal
Payroll and tax filing for small businesses and household employers. Get a 6-month free trial with our referral link.